Garrett Coolbaugh, b. April 8, 1795 in New Hope, Bucks Co., Pa. - d. Dec. 14, 1868 married Mary Hanna b. May 20, 1792,
Lower Smithfield, Northampton Co., Pa & d. Nov. 29, 1866. They are buried in Mt. Pleasent Cem., Grass Lake, Jackson Co., Mi.
Mary was the daughter of Benjamin Hanna and Sarah Seely.
__

1840 Henrietta, Jackson, Mi

1 male 5 & under 10 - Moses
2 males 10 & under 15 - unknown
1 male 20 & under 30 - Benjamin?
1 male 40 & under 50 - Garrett

1 female 15 & under 20 - Elizabeth
1 female 40 & under 50 - Mary



1850 Leoni, Jackson, Michigan
Garrit Coolbaugh 52 Farmer b. - N.J.
Mary 57 b. - Pa
Benjamin 30 Farmer b. - Pa
Moses 18 Farmer b. - N.Y.
Elizabeth 25 b. - Pa
__

1860 Leoni, Jackson, Mi
Garrit Coolbaugh 65 farmer b. N. Y. - d. 1868
Mary 67 b. Pa. - d. 1866

After Mary's death in 1866, Garrett Coolbaugh, b. Newhope, Pa., age 72 yrs, married Sarrah Hanna
b. Middle Smithfield, Pa., age 68yrs, on Sept. 25, 1867 in Grass Lake, Mi.
Witness to the marriage in 1867 were Benjamin and Martha (Price) Seidle also born in Pa.

1870 Grass Lake, Jackson, Michigan
Sarah Colbough 70 b. Pa
Sarah Coolbaugh d. March 3, 1874 in Grass Lake, Mi., widow, 74yrs, heart disease, b. N. Y.,
parents names listed as Cartwright parents b. N.Y.

Sarah Hanna Coolbaugh's death record lists her parents as Cartwright. Mary (Hanna) Coolbaugh's brother, William,
was married to Sarah Courtright, but the early records of Raymond Hanna has Sarah Courtright Hanna's death date as 1848.
If her parents were "Cartwrights" but her name when she married Garrett was Hanna and she was born in Middle Smithfield,
she had to have married one of our Hanna's. Who is this Sarah married to Garrett?
>>>>

Known Children of Garrett and Mary (Hanna) Coolbaugh

Benjamin Coolbaugh

1860 Everett, Newaygo, Michigan
B H Coolbaugh 40 lumber? b. Pa.
Lucy 25 b. N. Y.
Franklin 5 b. Indiana
Josephien 3 b. Michigan

Benjamin H. Coolbaugh marr. Lucy Ann Bower 29 Dec 1852 in Jackson, Mi.
__
1870 Everett, Newaygo, Michigan
Benj H Coolbaugh 50 lumber manufacturing b. Pa.
Lucy A 36 b. N. Y.
Franklin 15 school b. Indiana
Josephine 13 school b. Michigan
Eugenia C 10 school b. Michigan
Effie 5 b. Michigan
Mary L 1 b. Michigan
__

1880 Everett, Newaygo, Mi
B. H. Coolbaugh 50 farmer widowed (still 50 years old)
Josie 23 teacher
Gennice 19
Effie 13 Mary Effie?
Letta 11 Loretta?

(living daughter) Coolbaugh b. May 10, 1872 in Everett, Newaygo, Mi. dau. of Benjamin H., b. Pa, farmer & Lucy Coolbaugh b. unk.
there is an entry in the death records of an unnamed daughter of B.H. and Lucy dying on May 12, 1872 in Everett, age 1month.
they had a daughter born May 10 but a 1 month old died May 12, mistake? 1 day old?
and then there is this...
Lucy Coolbaugh, age unk, marr., d. May 12, 1872 in Everett of convulsions? b. in Everett, dau. of B. H. & Lucy Coolbaugh.
Her name is Lucy Coolbaugh, age unknown, she's married and the daughter of Benjamin & Lucy? another mistake?

I found a biography for Benjamin H. Coolbaugh that gave the date of death for his wife as May 14, 1871.
Lucy and the baby must have died May 12, 1872. Right?

Also from the biography: 5 living children, Franklin, Josephine, Eugenie, Effie and Loretta, 1 died in infancy.
Benjamin b. May 24, 1820 in Pa, son of Garrett & Mary (Hanna) Coolbaugh moved to Tompkins Co., N. Y. in 1827, then to
Allegany Co., N. Y. and in 1846 moved to Jackson Co., Mi. In 1852 he went to Indiana for two yrs then back to Jackson Co.
In Dec. 1852 he married Lucy Brower, dau. of Nathan D. & Prudence (Saunders) Brower.

I haven't been able to find Franklin after 1870.

Mary E. Coolbaugh 34yrs, b. Mi. living in White Cloud, teacher, dau. of B. F. Coolbaugh & Lucy Brower marr. April 7, 1900 to
James J. Terwillegar 27yrs, b. Mi, living in Everett, farmer, son of J.A. Terwillegar & Mary Wedick.

Loretta Coolbaugh, b. Nov 9, 1868 in Everett, Newaygo, Mi. dau. of B. H., b. Pa., farmer, & Lucy A. Coolbaugh b. N.Y.

Lettie Coolbaugh 25yrs, b. Everett, Mi., living in White Cloud, Mi., teacher, dau. of Benj. Coolbaugh & Lucy Bower
marr. July 24, 1895 to Geo. Wilson Decker 31yrs, b. Berlin, Mi., living in Barton, Mi., farmer, son of Eugene Decker & Catherine Mahoney. first marriage for her - second for him. marr. in Grand Rapids.

1900 Everett, Newaygo, Mi
James Terwillegar 28 b. Oct. 1872 b. Mi father B. N.Y. mother b. Ireland
Efie 29 b. Dec. 1870 b. Mi. father b. N.Y. mother b. Mi marr. under 1 yr 0 children
Benjiman Terwilligar 80 b. May 1820 b. N.Y parents b. N.Y. father
probably Benjamin H. Coolbaugh, James' marriage license has his father as J. A. Terwillegar.

1910 Everett, Newaygo, Mi
Janne J Hermilleyer 37 b. Mi father b, N. Y. mother b. Ireland farmer
Mary E 44 b. Mi. father b. Pa. mother b. Mi.
James D 2 b. Mi. parents b. Mi.
Benjamin H Coolbaugh 89 father-in-law b. Pa father b. N. J. mother b. Pa farmer
looks like James Herwillegar to me.

1920 Everett, Newaygo, Mi
James J Terwillegar 47 b. Mi. father b. N.Y. mother b. Ireland farmer general
Mary E Terwillegar 54 b. Mi. father b. Pa mother b. Mi
James D Terwillegar 12 b. Mi. parents b. Mi.

1930 Everett, Newaygo, Mi
James J Terwillegar 58 b. Mi. father b. N.Y. mother b. Ireland - farmer general - age at 1st marr. 27
Effie Terwillegar 64 b. Mi. father b. Pa. mother b. Mi. age at 1st marr. 34
De Vere Terwillegar - son - 23 b. Mi. parents b. Mi. laborer - county rd -
Euginea Fleaming 70 sister-in-law - widow - b. Mi. father b. Pa. mother b. Mi.
_________